Executive Summary

One of the significant challenges facing network operators today is the high capital cost of deploying next generation broadband network to individual homes or schools. Fiber to the home only makes economic sense for a relatively small percentage of homes or schools. One solution is a novel new approach under development in several jurisdictions around the world is to bundle the cost of next generation broadband Internet with the deployment of solar panels on the owners roof or through the sale of renewable energy to the homeowner. Rather than charging customers directly for the costs of deployment of the high speed broadband network theses costs instead are amortized over several years as a small discount on the customer’s Feed in Tariff (FIT) or renewable energy bill. There are many companies such as Solar City that will fund the entire capital cost of deploying solar panels on the roofs of homes or schools, who in turn make their money from the long term sale of the power from the panels to the electrical grid. In addition there are no Energy Service Companies (ESCOs) and Green Bond Funds that will underwrite the cost of larger installations.

For further information and detailed business analysis please contact Bill St. Arnaud at bill.st.arnaud@gmail.com.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Google's secret strategy with the Kansas City Fiber project

[I have long been perplexed at how Google plans to make a profit with their Kansas City Fiber project.
Originally the project was touted as an altruistic move by Google to really understand the underlying costs of deploying fiber in a large municipality. But as anyone who has been in the trenches can tell you, it is not the technology that determines the cost of a fiber deployment, but the tyranny of the take-up.  If you only have an initial 10% subscription rate then the initial cost,  regardless if the fiber is on poles or buried,   can be as much as $6000 per home. If the take-up is closer to 50% the initial cost drops to around $1500 per home and if the take-up is close to 100% then the cost can be as low as $500 per home.  The elbow in the curve for deploying fiber to the home is around 40% take up, at which it might, just might,  be conceivable to make a return in your investment.

 But Google is competing head on with the local cable and telephone incumbents who are not going to sit on their hands and watch Google take away 40% of their market.   Since their infrastructure has been paid for many times over through regulated rate of return on their basic service of cable TV and telephone, they can discount their prices to next to zero to prevent Google from making anywhere close to a 40% take up. So how is Google going to make a profit? 

In addition Google has announced that they plan to be a facilities based competitor rather than an open network provider. Many people may remember about 10 years ago in the .dot com boom a number of over builders announced plans to build fiber networks in competition with telecos and cablecos. Almost all of them went bust.

An intriguing hint on Google’s strategy is their plans to deploy fiber above the neutral wire on the poles.  Although far less cluttered than being below the neutral wire, this means that specially trained or electrical utility crews  must install the fiber.   It means that any moves adds, or changes to the fiber splice boxes etc will require these same expensive, unionized crews.  Generally when deploying a FTTH network, drops to individual homes are installed when a customer subscribes to the service, but with fiber installed above the neutral wire, it probably makes more sense to deploy all drops and splice boxes during the initial build out.  This also drives up front costs.

The only way for this type of strategy makes sense is if Google plans to fiber up every home from day one.   Google has a habit of shaking up the world.  Remember when it first offered free Gmail with one gigabyte storage?  The critics claimed it could not be done or Google would go bust. But Google proved them all wrong.

I suspect the same story is about to happen in Kansas City. Google will offer a basic free high speed Internet to each and every home, perhaps bundled with Google TV using their new set top box.   A variety of premium services will also be offered for additional fees. I would not be surprised that Google decided to offer a basic  1 Gbps service to every home. This would clearly differentiate Google from the cableco or telco and make it almost impossible for them to compete without undertaking a massive investment themselves.

Those who elected for the free service would have a Google side bar or screen splash on their TV or computers that are hooked to the Google set top box.  Google would then hope to make money by extending its current business model largely through Google TV.   Google may make extra money by also making their set top boxes WiFi 2.0 compatible so they can offer a city wide wireless network as well – much like Free is doing in France.

France’s Free network is probably the closest model that Google plans to emulate.  However even with Google TV I think Google is going to have a tough time making money.  To pay for the fiber alone, they will need to earn $10-$20 per month from each household over the next 5 years.  I don’t think highly selective advertising via Google TV will be enough.  Negotiating all the TV rights and channel offerings will also be a challenge.

The other potential area for Google to make money is operating as an ESCO (Energy Services Company). Google, as well as Microsoft and many other companies have tried to interest customers with tools to monitor their energy consumption.  But customers are not interested in saving energy – if they did everyone would drive at 30 miles per hour, as everyone knows gasoline consumption climbs significantly the faster you drive.  Energy  prices are also likely to drop because of abundance of gas and a surplus of electrical grid power. So rather than enticing customers to monitor their energy Google, in partnership with the local utility, could offer to peak manage the customer’s power usage, by briefly turning off air conditioners and hot water tanks.  They could also install smart thermostats and other devices to further reduce energy consumption.  The money in the energy savings would use to pay for the fiber or premium services, rather than being returned to the customer as piffling amount of energy savings.

Bundling  broadband with energy is the huge revenue opportunity for Google. The energy market has virtually remained unchanged since the 19th century.  The energy market is many, many orders magnitude larger than the advertising market.  Rather than trying to save customers a few dollars a month in energy, it would be far more effective to offer consumer something more tangible and with a higher perceived value such as free high speed Internet.

For more background information please see my blog on Free Fiber to the Home



R&E Network and Green Internet Consultant.

email:     Bill.St.Arnaud@gmail.com
twitter:  BillStArnaud
blog:       http://billstarnaud.blogspot.com/
skype:    Pocketpro


Admin said...

I have enjoyed your blog post with all of my friends. I will receommend your blog post
to my friends. This is a good post on earn at home.
I have come to learn new things from this blog post. I will read your blog regularly.
Thanks for your nice informative article.

Unknown said...

Hello! I just would like to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.mlm

Unknown said...

Other than having 1300 numbers, company owners should have reliable connection.

http://home-business-mentor.empowernetwork.com/ said...

How do You Think I went from zero (literally) to $49,000 my best week working from home, on the internet, from bed?It is called “INTERNET MARKETING” and, when done right, it can really save your traditional business and honestly, your financial future as well. At least it did it for me. Working an internet business from home has made a huge…
Home business mentor

Unknown said...

Thank's for your informative article.
ISP Video

macelis said...

The best apartments and rooms for new owners in California :- The menifee home builders are all recorded to fix as well as consequently broad the effort where it may occur to alteration as well as then it will disobediently resolution the subjects which are completed to temecula home builders fix the matters, there it can california homes transpire more as well as times too good adequate to require the likelihoods of attainment a home builder rebates dream household in any residence.

Unknown said...

I have gone through this site and it is really interesting, for more details follow our site:-The buy a new home California parts here mainly groupings the prominence of owning bed-sitters then it can alteration your impression to have a producers help in addition to own san bernardino home builders plan. The section is conversed in great linking with all temecula home builders facts trust in mind nevertheless not so moral for further california home builders to aspect for the variation or else the happing effects.

Unknown said...

I have gone through the site and read all blogs and this is a nice one:

The new home builders California article is all about home building and how it works for customers. There are naturally working and great round of process that help in making the home aright place to live los angeles home builders and enjoy with family. The details california home builders mentioned here are just as good like any other thing. The author was very clear with the article and new homes for sale all uses.

Unknown said...

I have gone through the informations that had been published in your site. I am sharing a very useful information which might help you a lot:

The buy a new home California is of sequence employed and uncountable corpulent of way that assistance in formation the as healthy as enjoy with national. The facts new home developments now remain just as dressed similar to some degree additional thing by means of the article also ventura home builders as long as are being considered best amongst the lot in all how to buy a new home places.

Unknown said...

As a financial developer you must be develop your projects with several way contact on:- The main aim of New Construction in Porter Ranch the article is to provide information for those who are associated and working for enhanced new schemes and other possible work making New Home Builders California enough beneficial things. The homes and plans are all inclusive which has los angeles new homes been found with professional builders in the market. The New Home Builder CA article is all about those are working here and covered.

Unknown said...

I like and love their blogs The other most important thing about website developing team is that they helps in planning important things based on your online business and gives Web Design South Florida the much needed exposure. The web developers are certainly one of a kind and it is worth to have them hired. Here is the Web Developers South Florida who are all known to deliver work as per the need.

Syed Ehtisham Haider Gilani said...

After reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely delighted to know about web design I found it and I’ll be book-mark and checking back often!

Melissa said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Melissa said...

[url=www.harriswalls.org]Smartphone pliable[\url]

Melissa said...